BEC WORLD PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITEDSET: BEC🇹🇭 TH

Internal Control · 2024

Internal Control — Board Opinion

Summary of the Board's Opinion on Internal Control

The 3rd Board of Directors Meeting of 2025, Date of meeting: February 21, 2025. The meeting acknowledged the summary report of the internal control system adequacy assessment according to the SEC's format for the year 2024 as follows:


Audit and Risk Committee (ARC) in the 9th Meeting of 2024, Date of meeting: November 6, 2024. The meeting acknowledged the summary report of the internal control system adequacy assessment according to the SEC's format for the year 2024, prepared by the Internal Audit Office (IA) as follows:

Objective: To ensure that the company has an appropriate and sufficient internal control system.

Process: The adequacy of the internal control system was assessed using the evaluation form provided by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), which was developed based on the COSO (The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission) framework.

Conclusion: The company has an effective internal control system that is generally acceptable.


Additionally, the Board of Directors acknowledged the auditor's report on the internal control system for the year 2024.

Summary: The auditor's office performed an audit, but did not examine all accounting items, instead using sampling methods. After studying and assessing the effectiveness of the internal control system in accounting, no material weaknesses were identified in the accounting internal control system. The auditor conducted the annual audit for 2024 and found no significant issues that required reporting to the Board of Directors.

Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System

Internal Control Framework Used

FrameworkDetail
The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO)

According to the results of the assessment of the adequacy of the Company’s internal control system in 2024 using the form prescribed by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) (Notification of the Capital Market Supervisory Board Tor Jor. 55/2020 effective on 1 September 2020), the Internal Audit & Risk Management Department reported the assessment results to the Audit & Risk Management Committee Meeting No.9/2024 held on 6 November 2024. In summary, from the assessment of the five components of the Company’s internal control consisting of control environment, risk assessment, control measures, information and communication systems, and monitoring system, the Internal Audit & Risk Management Department viewed that the Company’s internal control system was adequate and appropriate.


The summary of the internal control system under the COSO (The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission) concept is as follows:


1. Control environment

The Company sets up a reporting structure and appropriate determination of authority and responsibility to achieve the Company’s objectives under the oversight of the Board of Directors. The Company is committed to motivating, developing, and retaining talented personnel. The Company has a human resource management policy which has been notified to all employees to be adopted as an operational framework in various areas including organizational structure and workforce management, personnel recruitment and selection, performance management, personnel development, and role of supervisors in personnel management. The Board of Directors is independent from the management and is responsible for overseeing and developing internal control. The Company also assigns duties and responsibilities for internal control to personnel and requires an operation manual for important work system to be published for relevant parties to be used as operational written guidelines to achieve the organization’s objectives and comply with the principles of internal control. Adhering to integrity and ethics, the Company has created a written Code of Conduct that is published for all employees on the Company’s intranet and at new employee orientation and is sent to employees every year to acknowledge.


2. Risk assessment

The Company has clearly and adequately determined the organization’s objectives. The Company has identified and analyzed all types of risks that might affect objective achievement across the organization and considered potential risk of corruption. The Company is able to identify and assess changes that might affect the internal control system. The Company has created a risk management manual for executives in each department to be used as risk management guideline. Each department is responsible for assessing the risks, preparing their own risk management plans, and determining risk management and control guideline on an annual basis. The Internal Audit & Risk Management Department is responsible for coordinating, collecting, advising, and summarizing the risk assessment results to be presented to Risk Management Committee for consideration, monitoring, and review of such risk management and control.


3. Control measure

The Company sets up control measures to reduce risks that might prevent the organization from achieving its objectives to an acceptable level by establishing policies, regulations, procedure manual, which are approved in writing, to require establishing of internal control at all levels in the organization and separation of duties and responsibilities for check and balance. At present, there are a total of 84 operational systems with completed and implemented work manuals. Compliance department conducts a review to keep the manuals current and appropriate for the organizational structure. Moreover, the Company reviews its operating results by the management, determines regularly ensure that its operations comply with the laws, regulations, and requirements. In terms of information technology system control, the Company has developed its general control activities using technologies to help achieve the Company’s objectives such as security control of technological systems, acquisition control, and appropriate technological system development and maintenance.


4. Information and communication systems

The Company has set up sufficient data system internal and external communication channels to support internal control using the Company’s intranet and email systems to publish policies, rules/orders, guidelines, and news throughout the organization in order to provide employees access to operation related information, which promotes compliance with the internal control system. The Company has an efficient process to communicate information to stakeholders through the Company’s website.


5. Monitoring system

The Company regularly and consistently monitors and evaluates performance of department executives to ensure that operating results will achieve the Company’s targets. The operation system is also audited by the Internal Audit& Risk Department following the annual audit plan. The results of the audit are summarized and presented to relevant department executives for consideration of improvements of the operation systems. The results are then reported to the Audit & Risk Management Committee and later presented to the Board of Directors. The Internal Audit & Risk Management Department will follow up on management action plan and assess the adequacy of the internal control system on an annual basis.

Internal Control Deficiencies

Number of Deficiencies

MetricCurrent YearPrevious YearTwo Years Ago
Total number of internal control system deficiencies (cases)000

Audit Committee & Auditor Observations

Audit Committee's Opinion Differs from the Board's

No

Auditor Has Observations on Internal Control

No

Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit

Head of Internal Audit

3159

Audit Committee's Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit

The Company’s appointment, removal, and transfer of the Head of Internal Audit & Risk must be approved by the Audit & Risk Management Committee.


"In 2024, Miss Sarintip Charunsathienchai, Deputy Managing Director of the Internal Audit Bureau, resigned from her position, effective December 31, 2024, in order to accept a more attractive job offer."


However, Ms. Sarinthip Jarunsathianchai has resigned from her position as an employee of the Company, effective January 1, 2025. Consequently, the Audit and Risk Committee Meeting No. 10/2024, has reviewed the qualifications of the successor for the position of Head of Internal Audit. The committee has appointed

Ms. Sirigan Wongpin, currently serving as VP of Internal Audit, as the new Head of Internal Audit. Due to her expertise in internal auditing 3 years of experience at BEC World, as well as her participation in various essential training programs required for the role. Throughout her tenure at the company, she has consistently received performance evaluations from her supervisors that exceeded the established KPI targets.

Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit

Requires Audit Committee Approval

Yes

Description

The appointment, removal, or transfer of the Head of the Internal Audit Unit of the Company must be approved by the Audit and Risk Management Committee, as specified in

the Audit and Risk Committee Charter.


The individual appointed as Head of Internal Audit must possess appropriate educational qualifications, experience, knowledge, and skills sufficient to perform internal audit duties effectively.

Related Party Transactions

Has Related Party Transactions

Yes

Counterparties & Transactions

Monetary Unit

1000000

Counterparties with Potential Conflicts

NamePerson / Juristic PersonType of BusinessNature of RelationshipAs of Date (YYYY-MM-DD)
GMM Grammy Public Company Limited and SubsidiariesJuristic PersonThe primary business is a holding company focusing on integrated entertainment. Its core operations are conducted through subsidiaries and affiliates, encompassing music, home shopping, and media businesses.

Co-shareholders

2024-12-31T00:00
Millionaire Property FundPerson

Maleenont Tower Company Limited is a major unitholder in the Millionaire Property Fund, while Maleenont Tower Company Limited has its directors and executives as major shareholders.

2024-12-31T00:00
Marhasarn Company LimitedJuristic PersonAdvertising agency activities

Shareholders and co-director

2024-12-31T00:00
Mongkon Mahasan Company LimitedJuristic PersonAdvertising agency activities

Shareholders and co-director

2024-12-31T00:00
Veladee 2020 Company LimitedJuristic PersonTelevision production and advertising services

Shareholders and co-director

2024-12-31T00:00
Mr. Mavin TweepholPerson

Close relative with director

2024-12-31T00:00
Nopphadol KhemayotinPerson

Executive

2024-12-31T00:00

Transactions by Counterparty

Transactions
71.93 · Necessity: As a subsidiary of Company operates a television station, it shall sell advertising time as its ordinary business. The sale of advertising time to GMM Grammy Public Company Limited and subsidiaries with condition of advertising rate comparable to other external customers is then suitable and beneficial to the Company. · Description: Revenue from selling advertising time, which is considered as an ordinary business transaction · As of yesteryear: 72.6 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from selling advertising time · Audit committee opinion: It is a necessary and reasonable. · As of year before yesteryear: 95.23 · 0.0 · Necessity: As the Company and its subsidiaries operate a business of providing services for the sale of music rights for dramas, it shall sell music rights as its ordinary business. The sale of music rights to GMM Grammy Public Company Limited and subsidiaries with condition of price terms comparable to other external customers is then suitable and beneficial to the Company. · Description: Revenue from copyright and other services, which is considered as an ordinary business transaction · As of yesteryear: 0.25 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from copyright and other services · Audit committee opinion: It is a necessary and reasonable. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.17 · 0.3 · Necessity: As the Company and its subsidiaries organize events and exhibitions, it is necessary to obtain music licenses for such events. The terms and conditions offered by GMM Grammy Public Company Limited and its subsidiaries are comparable and therefore suitable and beneficial to the Company. · Description: Music copyright expenses, which is considered as an ordinary business transaction · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Music copyright expense · Audit committee opinion: It is a necessary and reasonable. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
114.98 · Necessity: Having considered the lease agreement, BEC World Group is of the view that the lease agreement is necessary and reasonable transaction. Due to the conducting of TV and radio station of subsidiaries, BEC World Group requires not only normal office area, but also some space for lease, having a special design to serve their business operation as studio and technical room for program production. In this regard, the lessor gave a special favor to design 12-storey building to suit such requirement. The leased premises could support long term business expansion and also, located in downtown, having suitable communication and transportation system, enabling to facilitate Company Group’s business operation. Due to the large space rental, BEC World’s rental price conditions are lower than the price that the lessor agrees with other lessees, based on general market price. · Description: The lease of office spaces: the Company and its subsidiaries entered into a lease agreement with Millionaire Property Fund in order to lease the office spaces in Maleenont Tower building (M I), located at 3199, and Maleenont Tower building (M II), located at 3199/1, Rama IV Road, Klongton Sub-District, Klongtoey District, Bangkok from Millionaire Property Fund. As of 31 December 2024, the total areas are 23,516.98 square meters, whereby these transactions are short-term lease agreements, which will be renewed in every one to three years. Furthermore, the Company and its subsidiaries also entered into the maintenance agreement and service agreement in relation to the said lease together with the lease agreement for convenience. · As of yesteryear: 115.3 · Nature of transaction: Service Cost - lease agreement not exceeding 3 years and utility charges for building which support broadcasting operation. · Audit committee opinion: It is a necessary and reasonable. · As of year before yesteryear: 109.84 · 68.02 · Necessity: Having considered the lease agreement, BEC World Group is of the view that the lease agreement is necessary and reasonable transaction. Due to the conducting of TV and radio station of subsidiaries, BEC World Group requires not only normal office area, but also some space for lease, having a special design to serve their business operation as studio and technical room for program production. In this regard, the lessor gave a special favor to design 12-storey building to suit such requirement. The leased premises could support long term business expansion and also, located in downtown, having suitable communication and transportation system, enabling to facilitate Company Group’s business operation. Due to the large space rental, BEC World’s rental price conditions are lower than the price that the lessor agrees with other lessees, based on general market price. · Description: The lease of office spaces: the Company and its subsidiaries entered into a lease agreement with Millionaire Property Fund in order to lease the office spaces in Maleenont Tower building (M I), located at 3199, and Maleenont Tower building (M II), located at 3199/1, Rama IV Road, Klongton Sub-District, Klongtoey District, Bangkok from Millionaire Property Fund. As of 31 December 2024, the total areas are 23,516.98 square meters, whereby these transactions are short-term lease agreements, which will be renewed in every one to three years. Furthermore, the Company and its subsidiaries also entered into the maintenance agreement and service agreement in relation to the said lease together with the lease agreement for convenience. · As of yesteryear: 68.02 · Nature of transaction: Selling and administrative expenses - lease agreement not exceeding 3 years and utility charges for office building. · Audit committee opinion: This is a necessary and reasonable. · As of year before yesteryear: 16.29 · 13.23 · Necessity: Having considered the lease agreement, BEC World Group is of the view that the lease agreement is necessary and reasonable transaction. Due to the conducting of TV and radio station of subsidiaries, BEC World Group requires not only normal office area, but also some space for lease, having a special design to serve their business operation as studio and technical room for program production. In this regard, the lessor gave a special favor to design 12-storey building to suit such requirement. The leased premises could support long term business expansion and also, located in downtown, having suitable communication and transportation system, enabling to facilitate Company Group’s business operation. Due to the large space rental, BEC World’s rental price conditions are lower than the price that the lessor agrees with other lessees, based on general market price. · Description: The lease of office spaces: the Company and its subsidiaries entered into a lease agreement with Millionaire Property Fund in order to lease the office spaces in Maleenont Tower building (M I), located at 3199, and Maleenont Tower building (M II), located at 3199/1, Rama IV Road, Klongton Sub-District, Klongtoey District, Bangkok from Millionaire Property Fund. As of 31 December 2024, the total areas are 23,516.98 square meters, whereby these transactions are short-term lease agreements, which will be renewed in every one to three years. Furthermore, the Company and its subsidiaries also entered into the maintenance agreement and service agreement in relation to the said lease together with the lease agreement for convenience. · As of yesteryear: 16.29 · Nature of transaction: Financial Costs - A part of lease agreement not exceeding 3 years, as prescribed in Accounting Standard Requirements No.16 regarding lease agreement · Audit committee opinion: This is a necessary and reasonable. · As of year before yesteryear: 14.25
0.06 · Necessity: As the company needs to diversify its programming lineup to retain viewership for the television station · Description: Production cost is an ordinary business transaction. · Nature of transaction: Production cost. · Audit committee opinion: It is a necessary and reasonable list.
1.23 · Necessity: Due to the company's need to diversify its programming lineup to retain viewership for the television station, as well as to produce various events. · Description: Production cost and event organization are an ordinary business transaction. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Production and Event organization · Audit committee opinion: It is a necessary and reasonable. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
35.42 · Necessity: The company needs to diversify its television programming to retain viewership. · Description: Drama production costs are an ordinary business transaction. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Drama production cost · Audit committee opinion: It is a necessary and reasonable. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
0.0 · Necessity: To reduce the maintenance costs of old vehicles (Year 2023) · Description: Sales of Used Vehicles (Year 2023) · As of yesteryear: 1.27 · Nature of transaction: Sales of Used Vehicles (Year 2023) · Audit committee opinion: There is a reasonable justification for transaction. (2023) · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0

Policy & Future Trends

Policy, Measures & Approval Process

The Company disclose the details of related party transaction, under the topic of “Related Party Transaction”. The Audit & Risk Committee shall consider the transaction in order to examine and ensure that the transaction is reasonable, the size of the transaction is appropriate, and the price should be comparable to the market price. The terms and conditions of the transaction must be in the normal course of business and the utmost benefit of the BEC World Group should be taken into consideration and has never conducted any Related Party Transaction in the form of financial assistance to other companies which are not subsidiary companies of BEC Group.


Regarding the acquisition or disposal of asset transaction or other related transactions, the Board of Directors and the Audit & Risk Committee supervise the Company and its subsidiaries to request approval for the transaction. BEC Group has complied with all regulations as specified by the Capital Market Supervisory Board, the Securities and Exchange Commission Thailand.


To prevent conflicts of interest, the Charter of the Board of Directors requires all directors to inform the Board of Directors of their interests and related persons before entering into any contract with the Company Group so that the Board of Directors shall be able to make decisions for the benefits of the Company Group and it is a practice and etiquette of the Board of Directors’ meeting that, in case that any directors, managements or related person have conflict of interest in any transaction, such director shall not attend the meeting during decision making of such transaction, in order to ensure independence in approving such transaction. The Compliance unit shall regularly survey the conflict of interest of directors and executives.


Consideration and approval of the Related Party Transaction (“RPT”), material transaction (“MT”) by the Board of Directors and the Audit & Risk Committee must be fully complied with the regulations prescribed by the Capital Market Supervisory Board, the Office of the SEC. The Compliance and Working System Development Department have set up an operation handbook, specifying the procedures for approving the transaction in accordance with the announced criteria. In proposing any RPT and/or MT to the Board of Directors Meeting or the shareholders’ meeting for approval, information relating to transaction must be disclosed in accordance with the regulations. The Audit and Risk Committee has a role in reviewing and giving opinions to the Board of Directors on the reasonableness of the transaction, comparing the terms and conditions of the transaction taking into account the best interests of the Company Group before proposing for consideration. After the transaction has been considered and approved, the Audit and Risk Committee will review the disclosure of the transaction in the financial statements and disclose the same in Form 56-1 One Report under the topic Related Parties Transactions (Transactions with persons who may have conflicts of interest) by disclosing sufficient and appropriate information.


Consideration of the Related Party Transaction: For any RPT during the year, besides monitoring and gathering details of transaction to ensure the compliance with the approval of the Board of Directors, the reasons and necessities of the transactions, including the size of transactions and the appropriate conditions must be taken into account for setting the criteria of the Related Party Transaction for the following year to be proposed for consideration and approval annually.

Future Trends in Related Party Transactions

The Company has a policy to avoid entering into any connected transactions with any related party which may cause “Conflict of Interest”, unless such transactions are in favor for business operation of BEC World Group as follows:


1. Sales of advertising time transaction: since the BEC World group has considered that the main revenue of the Company group is sales of advertising time, it shall sell the advertising time since to any customers including those with conflicts. However, the condition of advertising rate is comparable to other external customers.

2. Maleenont Tower building lease transaction: since BEC World Group spent considerable investment for studio construction and system works, BEC World Group still has a policy to renew the lease term to exploit the premises in Maleenont Tower as much as possible to be worth for its investment.

3. Hiring drama production is necessary because the company needs to source a variety of drama programs to be aired on the station in order to maintain the station's viewer base. Veladi (2020) Co., Ltd. is an experienced drama production company that is well-known and popular. Therefore, BEC World Group continues to have a policy of hiring drama productions if it will benefit the viewer base in the future.


With respect to connected transactions which may arise in the future, there shall be only normal transaction without any special transaction and the Board of Directors shall comply with Securities and Exchange Act, Notifications of Capital Market Supervisory Board and Regulations concerning Connected Transaction. The Company shall assign the Audit Committee to give opinion regarding the necessity and appropriateness for entering into any transactions between the Company and its subsidiaries with the related parties which may cause conflict of interests. For determination of consideration and all relevant conditions, the Audit Committee may acquire opinion from independent experts at the Company’s expense in the event that the Audit Committee has no expertise in considering any specific transaction.


Contents